It just gets worse for CERN and its attempts to reassure us that the Large Hadron Collider won’t make mincemeat of the planet.
It’s beginning to look as if a massive miscalculation in the safety reckonings means that CERN scientists cannot offer any assurances about the work they’re doing.
In a truly frightening study, Toby Ord and pals at the University of Oxford say that “while the arguments for the safety of the LHC are commendable for their thoroughness, they are not infallible.”
When physicists give a risk assessment, their figure is only correct if their argument is valid. So an important questions is then: what are the chances that the reasoning is flawed?
Ord and co say that roughly one in a 1000 scientific papers have to be withdrawn because of errors. And errors are by no means unknown among particle physicists, even those doing safety calculations
The Oxford team points to a 1999 study of the risk of a “dangerous event” at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider at the Brookhaven National Laboratory in New York state. This study calculated that the chance of such an event was tiny: 2 x 10^-9.
On the strength of this study, the Collider was deemed safe and operated for five years before a serious error was found in the calculations. (It turned out that the actual risk was closer to 10^-12 but the important point is that there was an error).
The problem is compounded when the chances of a planet-destroying event are deemed to be tiny. In that case, these chances are dwarfed by the chances of an error in the argument. “If the probability estimate given by an argument is dwarfed by the chance that the argument itself is flawed, then the estimate is suspect,” say Ord and co.
Nobody at CERN has put a figure on the chances of the LHC destroying the planet. One study simply said: “there is no risk of any significance whatsoever from such black holes”.
Which means we are left with the possibility that their argument is wrong which Ord reckons conservatively to be about 10^-4, meaning that out of a sample of 10,000 independent arguments of similar apparent merit, one would have a serious error.
Of course, this doesn’t mean that the LHC is dangerous, only that there is no reasonable assurance of safety which, as Mark Buchanan writing in New Scientist this week says, is not the same thing at all.
Even still, when it comes to the lives of 6.5 billion people, we need to have better assurances than this.
Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0810.5515: Probing the Improbable: Methodological Challenges Risks with Low Probabilities and High Stakes
[Via New Scientist]
Update: as an aid to the discussion here is a link to CERN’s analysis of the safety of LHC collisions, which was published last year.
Wonderful article on the many questions you answered me really great! Share this article the rest of my friends! Yours!
Hey there, You have done an excellent job. I’ll certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from this site.
Me gusta este blog Sitio mucho, Es una muy traqueteo terreno a y localización Info.
Thank you for that smart critique. Me & my neighbour were preparing to do some research about that. We received a excellent book on that matter from our local library and most books where not as influensive as your information and facts. I am pretty glad to see these information which I was searching for a lengthy time.
Beneficial post. I do think that do natural food eating plan will help us to get rid of our excess fat naturally. I own a wonderful knowledge about this diet around my review. You need to a look intended for moment during my own site.
http://hqfind.org.ua/in.cgi?4¶meter=tramadol&num=3
purchase cheap TRAMADOL in gainesville
cheapest online TRAMADOL
buying cheap TRAMADOL in midland
purchase cheap TRAMADOL in lagos
purchase cheapest TRAMADOL in nc
buy cheapest TRAMADOL in alexandria
buy cheapest TRAMADOL in hi
purchase TRAMADOL in chennai
TRAMADOL shipped by ups
purchase TRAMADOL in el paso
purchase cheap TRAMADOL online
order TRAMADOL in louisville
TRAMADOL in state of iowa
buy cheapest TRAMADOL in wuhan
TRAMADOL with next day delivery without prescription with free
TRAMADOL order overnight saturday delivery 77
purchase cheapest TRAMADOL in state of north carolina
buy cheap TRAMADOL in warren
cheap TRAMADOL in houston
how to order TRAMADOL online without a rx
buy cheapest TRAMADOL in saint petersburg
TRAMADOL in cleveland
order TRAMADOL online c o d
order cheapest TRAMADOL in lewisville
order TRAMADOL in mesquite
buy cheapest TRAMADOL in norman
TRAMADOL in riyadh
buy TRAMADOL in sunnyvale
purchase cheapest TRAMADOL in pittsburgh
buying cheapest TRAMADOL in state of connecticut
buy TRAMADOL fda dea approved
TRAMADOL cod $10.00 coupon
buy TRAMADOL in bellevue
purchase cheap TRAMADOL in pueblo
cheapest TRAMADOL in canada
get TRAMADOL in waco
buying TRAMADOL in the santo domingo
order TRAMADOL in san antonio
TRAMADOL in oceanside
buying TRAMADOL in billings
buying cheapest TRAMADOL in chongqing
buy cheap TRAMADOL with dr prescription
TRAMADOL meds no prescription needed
buy cheap TRAMADOL in chicago
get cheap TRAMADOL in carrollton
Somebody essentially forbear to liberate sincerely posts I would state. This is the extraordinarily first time I frequented your network page and hence far? I surprised with the investigate you made to initiate this noteworthy publish incredible. Outlandish job!
Once I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now every time a comment is added I get four emails with the identical comment. Is there any approach you can take away me from that service? Thanks Free Submission
Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. Thanks for sharing.
whoah this weblog is great i really like studying your articles. Stay up the good paintings! You recognize, a lot of individuals are hunting round for this information, you can aid them greatly.
This blog won’t show up correctly on my iphone 4 – you might want to try and fix that
Our intention can be to evaluation problems identified according even although in the path of distinctive genres of composing.
Hiya very cool website!! Man .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally…I’m satisfied to seek out numerous helpful information right here in the submit, we’d like develop extra strategies on this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .