Do nuclear decay rates depend on our distance from the sun?

radioactive-decay.jpg

Here’s an interesting conundrum involving nuclear decay rates.

We think that the decay rates of elements are constant regardless of the ambient conditions (except in a few special cases where beta decay can be influenced by powerful electric fields).

So that makes it hard to explain the curious periodic variations in the decay rates of silicon-32 and radium-226 observed by groups at the Brookhaven National Labs in the US and at the Physikalisch-Technische Bundesandstalt in Germany in the 1980s.

Today, the story gets even more puzzling. Jere Jenkins and pals at Purdue University in Indiana have re-analysed the raw data from these experiments and say that the modulations are synchronised with each other and with Earth’s distance from the sun. (Both groups, in acts of selfless dedication,  measured the decay rates of silicon-32 and radium-226 over a period of many years.)

In other words, there appears to be an annual variation in the decay rates of these elements.

Jenkins and co put forward two theories to explain why this might be happening.

First,  they say a theory developed by John Barrow at the University of Cambridge in the UK and Douglas Shaw at the University of London, suggests that the sun produces a field that changes the value of the fine structure constant on Earth as its distance from the sun varies during each orbit. Such an effect would certainly cause the kind of an annual variation in decay rates that Jenkins and co highlight.

Another idea is that the effect is caused by some kind of interaction with the neutrino flux from the sun’s interior, which could be tested by carrying out the measurements close to a nuclear reactor (which would generate its own powerful neutrino flux).

It turns out, that the notion of that nuclear decay rates are constant has been under attack for some time. In 2006, Jenkins says the decay rate of manganese-54 in their lab decreased dramtically during a solar flare on 13 December.

And numerous groups disagree over the decay rate for elements such as titanium-44, silicon-32 and cesium-137. Perhaps they took their data at different times of the year.

Keep em peeled beause we could hear more about this. Interesting stuff.

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0808.3283: Evidence for Correlations Between Nuclear Decay Rates and Earth-Sun Distance

108 Responses to “Do nuclear decay rates depend on our distance from the sun?”

  1. [...] Estas ideas tienen implicaciones más amplias. Giacosa y Pagliara dicen que este efecto podría explicar otras extrañas variaciones periódicas en las tasas de descomposición que los físicos han observado en escalas de tiempo mucho mayores. Ya hemos revisado algunas aquí. [...]

  2. Moncler Quilted Jackets for Women in our outlet store is your best choose. The elegant design will improve your status. They are cheap with excellent quality.

  3. houdini help desk…

    [...]Do nuclear decay rates depend on our distance from the sun? « the physics arXiv blog[...]…

  4. Henryk says:

    Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Thank you so much, However I am going through difficulties with your RSS. I don’t know the reason why I cannot join it. Is there anyone else having the same RSS issues? Anyone that knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

  5. Jacob says:

    Hi there, its pleasant piece of writing about media print, we all be familiar
    with media is a fantastic source of data.

  6. Uncle B says:

    Enough variation to defeat atomic clocks? To save us all from the Plutonium spread around the world since 1945?

  7. Fire-brand watches like Rolex, Audemars Piguet or A Lange Sohne are worldwide eminent for their unpaid qualities, as well as for their very striking cost tag. over the years, these brand names have become a representative of the epicurism watchfulness diligence. At the same duration, another activity was developing at a go hungry step, that of the brand imitations like Voluptuousness A Lange Sohne replica Watches . The relatively low-priced autograph copy watches are no longer manufactured in close and considered to be illegal, on the adverse, its area of traffic entrep?′t divide has risen especially in recent years. Race like autograph copy watches, for they be like the first and as deafening as those original.

Leave a Reply